Catherine Classic – Phone Mail Guide / Walkthrough

Phone Mail Guide

Other Catherine Classic Guides:

Throughout the game at the Stray Sheep, Vincent can receive numerous text messages and phone calls from Catherine, Katherine, Trisha, and others. Some of these have no effect and are purely informational, while others impact the karma meter and can have a large effect towards Law or Chaos.

In most cases, responding in a certain way to a text message from Catherine or Katherine will lead to another text or picture message, and sometimes after that a phone call. Each of these messages is another opportunity to interact with them and alter your karma meter, so as to gain a deeper understanding in your relationships.

Day #1

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 1-1KRIOS PHONETo all customers 1/2
Mail 1-2KRIOS PHONETo all customers 2/2
Mail 1-3KatherineChecking in
Mail 1-4Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 1-5KatherineWait a second…Positive response for Mail 1-3

Mail 1-3

From: Katherine

Subject: Checking in

Like I said before, I’m having
dinner with some old friends.
It’s surprising… Most of them
are already married, and almost
half of them have kids. They’re
all showing off pictures of
their families and it makes me
feel left out.
Maybe it’s time for us to get
out of our comfort zone too.

Note: If you obtain at least 3 Law points during this text, Katherine will respond with Mail 1.5. Be sure NOT to save first, or you will automatically close the cell phone & not give Katherine time to respond.

Max Law Response (3.5 points)

  • Does it bother you?
  • I worry about it too sometimes.
  • Maybe we should talk about this.
  • Drive home safe, okay?

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • Does it bother you?
  • Is this some kind of test?
  • I think we’re okay as we are.
  • It’ll just stress you out more.
  • Let’s catch a movie sometime. See ya!

Max Chaos Response (4.5 points)

  • Sorry, can’t think right now.
  • It’s important to be comfortable in life.
  • I’m pretty tired right now…
  • So…yeah.

Mail 1-5

From: Katherine

Subject: Wait a second…

Are you out drinking at Stray
Sheep again? You know you have

work tomorrow!
Geez…
Take it easy, ok?

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text, Katherine will give you a phone call.

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Guilty as charged.
  • I’ll make sure I don’t drink enough to get a hangover.
  • Good night, Katherine.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • No, I’m not there.
  • I don’t need that place.
  • Good night, Katherine.

Max Chaos Response (3 points)

  • You don’t own me.
  • Sometimes a man needs a drink, you know?
  • L8r.

Day #2

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 2-1Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 2-2KatherineAre you at SS again?
Mail 2-3CatherineIs this reaching you?
Mail 2-4Midnight VenusAbout the passage of time
Mail 2-5CatherineR U getting these?No response for Mail 2-3
Mail 2-6KatherineAbout tomorrowPositive response for Mail 2-2
Mail 2-7Catherine (PIC)YAYPositive response for Mail 2-3 or Mail 2-5

Mail 2-2

From: Katherine

Subject: Are you at SS again?

Are you out drinking again?

I came by your apartment today,
but you weren’t there. I want to
talk to you about something, but
I’ll do it tomorrow.
Oh, yeah… Your place is
filthy! I told you, you have to
empty the trash more often. I
took it out this time, but start
being more careful, ok?
That’s all. Good night.

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text, Katherine will respond with Mail 2-6.

Max Law Response (4 points)

  • Sorry I wasn’t home.
  • What did you want to talk about?
  • I think I know what you’re gonna tell me…
  • …I understand.
  • Good night, Katherine.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Chaos/0.5 Law points)

  • Sorry I wasn’t home.
  • We’ll talk tomorrow.
  • I bet you’re tired, too.
  • Bye.

Max Chaos Response (3 points)

  • Don’t touch my stuff.
  • Sorry, I’m too tired to talk right now.
  • Man, I’m sleepy…

Mail 2-3

From: Catherine

Subject: Is this reaching you?

Hey, Vincent!

If you get this, let me know, k?
If you do, I’ll send you a
picture!
You know you wanna see it!

Note: If you obtain at least 2 Chaos points during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 2-7.

Note: If you ignore this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 2-5.

Max Law Response (1 points)

  • Who is this?
  • Do I know you?

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Law points)

  • Who is this?
  • Don’t message me again.

Max Chaos Response (3 points)

  • This is Vincent.
  • PIX NAO PLZ!!

Mail 2-5

From: Catherine

Subject: R U getting these?

I’m gonna send this 1 more

time just to be sure.
Hello?

Note: If you obtain at least 2 Chaos points during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 2-7.

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Uh… Who are you?
  • Can I have your name?

Most Neutral Response (1 Chaos point)

  • I got your message.
  • Don’t talk to me.

OR

Most Neutral Response (1 Law point)

  • Uh… Who are you?
  • You’re bothering me.

Max Chaos Response (2 points)

  • I got your message.
  • What do you want?

Mail 2-6

From: Katherine

Subject: About tomorrow
Um…

Can I meet you for lunch
tomorrow?
You don’t need to reply to me
now. Just meet me at the cafe
for lunch. I’ll be there…
Please come.
Good night.

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text, Katherine will give you a phone call.

Max Law Response (3.5 points)

  • Huh? What happened?
  • Sounds important, I’ll definitely be there.
  • Go easy on yourself, okay?
  • Well, good night, Katherine.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • Okay, I’ll try to make it.
  • See you tomorrow, then.

Max Chaos Response (1 point)

  • Well, I’ll go if I can.
  • Bye.

Mail 2-7 Pic

From: Catherine

Subject: YAY

Thanks for writing back! ♥

Be sure to save my address, k?
I’m saving yours! v(^_^)v
Here’s the reward I promised.
Don’t show it to anyone else!

Day #3

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 3-1Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 3-2KatherineAre you drinking?
Mail 3-3CatherineHey!
Mail 3-4Midnight VenusBooze & You
Mail 3-5KatherineI’m sorryPositive response for Mail 3-2
Mail 3-6Catherine (PIC)OkiesPositive response for Mail 3-3
Mail 3-7CatherineOh…Negative response for Mail 3-3

Mail 3-2

From: Katherine

Subject: Are you drinking?

Are you still at the Stray

Sheep? Haven’t you been there
every night lately?
I thought you had an upset
stomach today… Why are you
drinking again?
Please, take care of yourself.
You’re not just living for you
anymore.

Note: If you obtain at least 1 Law point during this text, Katherine will respond with Mail 3-5.

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Sorry…
  • But it’s important to be with my friends, too.
  • Why, what’s going on? Is something wrong?

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Chaos/0.5 Law points)

  • Sorry…
  • Can’t I at least hang out with my friends?
  • Stop assuming the worst about me.

Max Chaos Response (2 points)

  • I’ll do what I feel like.
  • I don’t need you on my back every second.
  • I’ll talk to you later.

Mail 3-3

From: Catherine

Subject: Hey! ♡

How are you doing? ♥

Are you still at work?
Are you done yet?

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Chaos points during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 3-6.

Note: If you obtain at least 0.5 Law points during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 3-7.

Max Law Response (0.5 points)

  • Sorry, I’m still at work.
  • Sorry, gotta run.
  • Bye.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Chaos points)

  • Sorry, I’m still at work.
  • Sorry, gotta run.
  • Good night, Catherine.

OR

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Law points)

  • Sorry, I’m still at work.
  • Sorry, gotta run.
  • Bye.

Max Chaos Response (2 points)

  • Yeah, I’m done.
  • I can’t see you today, though. I’m busy.
  • I’ll text you again later.

Mail 3-5

From: Katherine

Subject: I’m sorry

Sorry. Maybe I was a little too

harsh.
I mean, I did overload you with
stuff about maternity leave and
money…
But it’s important, so be sure
to keep it in mind, okay?

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text, Katherine will give you a phone call.

Mail 3-6 Pic

From: Catherine

Subject: Okies

KK. I understand! ♡

Hehehe! (^3^) Mwah!
Oh, I took a new picture.
Here!

Note: If you ignore or obtain at least 1.5 Chaos points during this text, Catherine will give you a phone call.

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Don’t send me pictures!
  • You can’t just send me stuff like this without any warning.
  • Let’s stop right here.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • Hehehe? Do I want to know?
  • What are you planning…?

Max Chaos Response (2 points)

  • Hehehe? Do I want to know?
  • What have you got in mind…?
  • Heh heh…

Mail 3-7

From: Catherine

Subject: Oh…

That’s a shame… (;_;)
K, I’ll hold it in for now.

But you’re such a good guy!
Work is important! Work hard!
I’m proud of you! ♥

Max Law/Most Neutral Response (No change)

  • Do not respond.

Minimum Chaos Response (0.5 Chaos points)

  • Good.
  • Well, good night.

Max Chaos Response (2.5 points)

  • Thanks.
  • It’s not like we’re never going to see each other again…
  • Good night, Catherine.

Day #4

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 4-1Catherine (PIC)Show & Tell!!!
Mail 4-2TobyDo you like cake?
Mail 4-3TobyShit! IGNORE LAST TEXT!
Mail 4-4OrlandoI’m working overtime
Mail 4-5Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 4-6CatherineHeyyyy
Mail 4-7KatherineAbout this morning
Mail 4-8Midnight VenusYour fellow customers
Mail 4-9CatherineYou meanie!Positive response from Mail 4-6
Mail 4-10KatherineI…Positive or no response from Mail 4-7
Mail 4-11CatherineRe:Re: You meanie!Negative response from Mail 4-9

Mail 4-1 Pic

From: Catherine

Subject: Show & Tell!!! ♥♥

Hi Vincent!♡

I’m sending you a special picture!♥ Try
not to act surprised if you’re opening it
at work or something. Just thinking of
your reaction when you see this is
making me laugh!

Mail 4-6

From: Catherine

Subject: Heyyyy

How’s it going, Vincent? ♥

What are you doing right now?

Note: If you obtain at least 1 Chaos point during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 4-9.

Max Law Response (1 point)

  • Why do you care?
  • I can’t see you today.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Chaos/0.5 Law points)

  • Why do you care?
  • Grownups have to work for a living.
  • We’ll talk later.

Max Chaos Response (1 point)

  • I’m drinking with friends.
  • We’ll talk later.

Mail 4-7

From: Katherine

Subject: About this morning

Hi.

This morning must have been hard
for you. Well… I guess I was in the
wrong too, for showing up so
suddenly.
But…… I wanted to talk to you a
little more, face-to-face.

Note: If you ignore the text or obtain at least 2 Law points during this text, Katherine will respond with Mail 4-10.

Max Law Response (3.5 points)

  • I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to chase you away.
  • I wanted to protect you…
  • I want to talk to you, too.
  • I really care about you.
  • Good night, Katherine.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Chaos/0.5 Law points)

  • I can’t get that stink out of my room…
  • Come see me another time.
  • We can talk about the details the next time we see each other.
  • Well, good night, Katherine.

Max Chaos Response (3 points)

  • It’s okay.
  • But you did surprise me, too.
  • Actually, I’m too tired to talk, so I’ll see you later.

Mail 4-9

From: Catherine

Subject: You meanie!

Why are you blowing me off!?

I only wanted to see you…
…Can I call you, then?
Calling’s okay, right?

Note: If you obtain at least 1 Chaos point during this text, Catherine will give you a phone call. Picking it up will give you another Chaos point.

Note: If you obtain at least 0.5 Law points during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 4-11.

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Don’t call me.
  • I mean it. Stop calling me.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • You’re so persistent…
  • We’ve got nothing to talk about.

Max Chaos Response (1 point)

  • You’re so persistent…
  • I’ve got to run. No time to talk.

Mail 4-10

From: Katherine

Subject: I…

I’m… really confused right
now…

I mean, you’ve been acting
really strange this week.
This has never happened before.
I’m worried about us…

Note: If you obtain at least 1 Law point during this text, Katherine will give you a phone call. Ignoring it gives you a Chaos point.

Max Law Response (2 points)

  • Yeah, I’m sorry about that.
  • I need to make sure I’m ready emotionally.
  • Let’s get together and talk things out soon.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Chaos/0.5 Law points)

  • Stop worrying so much.
  • I really care about you.
  • See ya.

Max Chaos Response (1.5 points)

  • Stop worrying so much.
  • I’m tired…
  • Don’t drink too much. It’s not that good for you. Take it from me.

Mail 4-11

From: Catherine

Subject: Re:Re: You meanie!

You’re so boring!

( ` ロ ‘ )/

Max Law Response (0 points)

  • It’s not like you have anything interesting to say.
  • Bye.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • It’s not like you have anything interesting to say.
  • Bye.

Max Chaos Response (1 point)

  • Next time, ok?
  • Good night.

Day #5

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 5-1Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 5-2KatherineEat your cake
Mail 5-3Catherine (PIC)Some good medicine!
Mail 5-4CatherineI’m wondering
Mail 5-5KatherineHey…Positive response from Mail 5-2
Mail 5-6Midnight VenusThe Mysterious Meter
Mail 5-7CatherineOh…Positive response from Mail 5-4

Mail 5-2

From: Katherine

Subject: Eat your cake

Eat that piece of cake I gave
you, or it’s going to get stale.
I know we couldn’t talk much
yesterday. I’ve been busy with
work, and it’s hard to make
time.
I might not be able to pick up
the phone sometimes…I’ll give
you a call soon.

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text or ignore it, Katherine will respond with Mail 5-5.

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Sorry, I’ve been busy, too.
  • But… I have something that I need to talk to you about, too.
  • I need to think some more before I do, though.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • You surprised me when you came over so suddenly.
  • So, are you home alone right now?
  • Not that I’m implying anything…

Max Chaos Response (2 points)

  • Please don’t come over without calling me beforehand.
  • Is work really keeping you so busy?
  • Ugh… That’s not the way I meant it.
  • I’m pretty tired, so I’ll talk to you later.

Mail 5-3 (Caterine Picture Collection)

From: Catherine

Subject: Some good medicine!

Here’s something that’ll make
you feel better! ♡
Well? Is it working? (^_~)
Oh, sorry for sending that last

one while you were at work. I
hope I didn’t get you in any
trouble… ♥
Anyway, take care! ♥

Max Law Response (1 point)

  • I told you already! You can’t keep doing this!
  • Please stop sending me these pictures.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • This is crossing the line…
  • These pictures are going to make things really complicated for me.
  • Well, whatever… See ya.

Max Chaos Response (2.5 points)

  • Niiiiiiiiiiice.
  • Have I ever mentioned my perfect 10?
  • Don’t go overboard, okay?

Note: You can back out of and re-view this attachment several times to get alternate pictures. A new picture is unlocked for each of the Good/True Endings you view (minus Good Freedom): Catherine Good, Catherine True, Katherine Good, Katherine True, and True Freedom. You can check each picture below.

Unlocked from the beginning

Unlocked after viewing 1 Good/True ending

Unlocked after viewing 2 Good/True endings

Unlocked after viewing 3 Good/True endings

Unlocked after viewing 4 Good/True endings

Unlocked after viewing 5 Good/True endings

Mail 5-5

From: Katherine

Subject: Hey…

Did something happen? I hope I’m
imagining things…
Oh yeah, I’m meeting with a
friend tomorrow, so if you want
to call me, do it in the
afternoon.
Aren’t you busy with work too?
Try to take it easy, ok?

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Sorry, it’s nothing.
  • Thanks for worrying about me.
  • Good night, Katherine.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • Sorry, I’m just tired…
  • Maybe it’s because I’m drunk.
  • Well, good night.

Max Chaos Response (1.5 points)

  • Does it matter?
  • I have a lot on my mind, too.
  • I’m going to drink a little more here, so I’ll talk to you later.

Mail 5-4

From: Catherine

Subject: I’m wondering
Hey…

Is it true that you have a
tummyache?

You’re not lying to me…
or hiding anything from me…
…Are you?

Note: If you ignore the text or obtain at least 1.5 Chaos points during this text, Catherine will respond with Mail 5-7.

Max Law Response (0 points)

  • Ignore this mail

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • Ignore this mail

Max Chaos Response (3 points)

  • I’m not lying!
  • I’ve been really tired lately.
  • Come on, cheer up.
  • I wish I could see you…
  • Good night, Catherine.

Mail 5-7

From: Catherine

Subject: Oh…

I just want to be with you,
Vincent.
That’s all…
But you say these things that
don’t make any sense to me…
It worries me. Do you think I’M
the bad guy here?

Note: If you obtain at least 2 Law points during this text, Catherine will give you a phone call.

Max Law Response (2 points)

  • You’re starting to bug me.
  • No matter what you say, I still can’t see you tonight.
  • So, that’s that. See you.

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • I’m only trying to make sure…
  • But I can’t see you tonight.
  • Let’s discuss this some other time, okay?

Max Chaos Response (3 points)

  • I didn’t say you were the bad guy.
  • In fact, I’m the bad guy.
  • I’m sorry if I made you mad.
  • Come on, don’t be mad.
  • Absence makes the heart grow fonder, right?
  • You don’t need me tonight. Stop causing trouble.

Day #6

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 6-1Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 6-2KatherineWhat’s going on?
Mail 6-3Catherine (PIC)I’m so excited!
Mail 6-4Midnight VenusThe Rapunzel Puzzle
Mail 6-5KatherineCan I trust you?Positive response from Mail 6-2

Mail 6-2

From: Katherine

Subject: What’s going on?

Vincent…
Have you gotten involved in
something bad?
If that’s the case, tell me.
Tell me the truth.
Your problems are my problems
now.

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text, Katherine will respond with Mail 6-5.

Max Law Response (3 points)

  • Don’t worry about it.
  • You don’t have to worry about anything.
  • Sorry. I’ll explain everything to you when it’s all over.
  • I love you, Katherine.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Law points)

  • You’re worrying too much…
  • It was just a misunderstanding.
  • I’m sorry you’re worried about me.
  • Good night, Katherine.

Max Chaos Response (2.5 points)

  • You don’t believe me?
  • Why are you telling me this?
  • It’s not a big deal.
  • Bye.

Mail 6-3 Pic

From: Catherine

Subject: I’m so excited!♡♡♡

I hope you’re working hard!
I love when you talk about your
job.♡
Oooooh!
It’s our first *real* date
tomorrow! I’m soooooooooooo
excited!♥♥♥
( >▽<)/
Let’s do something else after we
go to the movies!

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Chaos points during this text, Catherine will give you a phone call.

Mail 6-5

From: Katherine

Subject: Can I trust you?

How can I believe what you’re
saying…?
I hate to have to say that, but
you were being weird at lunch.
I’m sorry, but I’m not so
gullible that I can just believe
whatever comes out of your
mouth.
I need to hear the truth from
you. We’re going to be sharing
our lives together!

Note: If you obtain at least 1.5 Law points during this text, Katherine will give you a phone call. Sheep

Max Law Response (2 points)

  • It’s really settled now. Trust me.
  • There’s really nothing for you to worry about.
  • You’re the most important thing to me, always.
  • Thank you for worrying about me.

Most Neutral Response (0.5 Law points)

  • It’s really settled now. Trust me.
  • I’m not going to cause you any trouble.
  • You can relax.
  • Thanks for messaging me.

Max Chaos Response (1.5 points)

  • Quit grilling me…
  • Even if I told you, you probably wouldn’t understand.
  • Hasn’t this been enough? Good night.

Day #7

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 7-1Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 7-2KatherineHey
Mail 7-3Midnight VenusThe Experience Enigma

Mail 7-2

From: Katherine

Subject: Hey

How are you, Vincent?
I went to your apartment this
afternoon. I thought we’d be able
to finally talk, since it’s the
weekend.
But you weren’t there.
You’re at work, right…?

Max Law Response (1.5 points)

  • Thanks for texting me.
  • It makes me realize just how important you are to me…

Most Neutral Response (0 points)

  • I guess we just missed each other.
  • I’m so sorry for everything…

Max Chaos Response (0 points)

  • I guess we just missed each other.
  • I’m so sorry for everything…

Note: Please note if you answer “Neutral” for this text, it will appear like you get Law points. This is not the case – if you have Max Chaos, you will still get the Catherine True Ending. You can see in the next cutscene that your karma meter is not affected like it initially shows.

Day #8

MailSenderSubjectPrerequisite
Mail 8-1Midnight VenusCongratulations!
Mail 8-2KRIOS PHONE (PIC)Attachments issues

Email 8-2 (Ending)

From: KRIOS PHONE

Subject: Attachments issues

To: Mr. Vincent Brooks
Some of our newer cell phone
models have been having trouble
accessing our online media
storage service. We apologize
for the inconvenience.
We are handling this issue by
sending our users the data they
were storing online via text
messages. These messages will
not cost you anything to
receive.

You can back out of and re-view this attachment several times to get alternate pictures. A new picture is unlocked for each of the Good/True Endings you view: the Catherine Good Ending, Catherine True Ending, Katherine Good Ending, Katherine True Ending, and Freedom True Ending. This excludes the Freedom Good Ending.

Below are picture for each ending.

Unlocked from the beginning

Unlocked after viewing 1 Good/True ending

Unlocked after viewing 2 Good/True endings

Unlocked after viewing 3 Good/True endings

Unlocked after viewing 4 Good/True endings

Unlocked after viewing 5 Good/True endings

I hope you enjoy the game!

More of this sort of thing:


Written by Sennzai

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *