All’s Fair Trophy Guide
All’s Fair – Red Dead Online: Successfully counter a rival Posse’s Free Roam mission.
You will likely get this playing normally while online. Occasionally while you are in a posse, you will get a message that pops up on screen telling you that another posse has stolen something of interest during their free roam mission. You will now need to go and intercept them. You’ll either need to kill or get the members of the rival posse to flee so you can claim their loot. Deliver it to the marked spot on your map and you will get the trophy. This is fairly easy to do if you have a good posse, but more difficult if you are playing by yourself or are stuck in a posse with people that are just messing around.
If you are having a lot of trouble, you can boost this with one other person so find a partner and wait for them to get a free roam mission you can counter. Also, occasionally a rival posse with mark you for assassination. You can also get the trophy by escaping for five minutes. This is likely the easiest way to get the trophy if you are playing solo.